The Case Against AI Everything, Everywhere, All at Once

The article presents a critical perspective on the current trajectory of Artificial Intelligence (AI) development and its implications for society. Here's a summarized version:

• The author, deeply involved in the evolution of the internet and networking, expresses concerns over the direction AI is taking. Unlike the inclusive early days of internet development, current discussions about AI are dominated by a few powerful stakeholders, leading to what the author terms as "Authoritarian Intelligence."

• AI is not merely chat bots. The field has grown to encompass machine learning technologies like Generative AI that can produce content. However, this type of AI often prioritizes mimicry over true creativity or accuracy.

• The article suggests that the seeming inevitability of tech's evolution is a constructed narrative. Historian Timothy Snyder describes this as the politics of inevitability – the belief that the future is pre-determined, with no alternative paths.

• In Silicon Valley, there's a culture of inevitability fueled by corporations, investors, and media, wherein new technologies are presented using language associated with positive values, thus encouraging widespread adoption.

• This pattern was previously observed with social media, smartphones, and cloud computing. Although these technologies promised community and connection, they also led to societal polarization, toxic interactions, and issues of data privacy and bias.

• Now, AI is at a similar crossroads. A few dominant leaders advocate for large-scale AI implementations as the only way forward, potentially resulting in undue power and profits concentrated in their hands.

• While these leaders speak about safety and responsibility, they prioritize their interests over societal well-being, conducting experiments that could impact people's lives and livelihoods.

• The risks associated with AI are multifaceted. Immediate concerns include disinformation via deep fakes, data privacy breaches, and biased decision-making. Broader societal risks entail job losses, environmental impacts, and opaque AI systems making decisions on our behalf.

• At its core, the unchecked development and deployment of AI could challenge the very essence of humanity. Overemphasizing "intelligence" might cause us to become more machine-like, potentially leading to a society where human values are secondary or even obsolete.

The article underscores the need for reflection, discussion, and regulation in the field of AI, advocating for a more considered and inclusive approach to its evolution and integration into society.

The primary goal should be human welfare and dignity, with innovation serving these ends.

• The open systems environment from the 1970s and 80s can be a model, wherein power was distributed among various stakeholders, leading to balanced decisions and minimized risks.

• The omnipresence of AI is not a foregone conclusion. It's essential to critically evaluate the tools and the individuals steering their development.

• Both private and public sector leaders can counteract the push for unchecked AI proliferation by resisting the dominant narrative and taking deliberate, thoughtful actions.

• By creating intentional pauses, society can craft meaningful national and international policies that distribute power equitably and safeguard human rights.

• Independent funding and ethical guidelines can stimulate a research community that champions innovation without compromising on ethical considerations.

• With appropriate priorities and safeguards, AI can be harnessed for significant positive impacts, such as advancing scientific knowledge, treating diseases, fostering new industries, enhancing joy, and preserving human dignity and individual uniqueness.

The piece calls for a balanced approach to AI, championing its potential benefits while remaining vigilant about its challenges and risks.

Ethical and Societal Implications of AI

• 🌍 The themes in horror movies, such as atomic anxiety in the 50s, can be directly linked to real-world events like the Cold War and the use of nuclear weapons, showcasing the impact of historical traumas on art and culture.

• 😮 The CEO of open AI's statement that "I think we should regulate AI" is compared to giving chainsaws to fourth graders, highlighting the potential dangers of unregulated AI.

• 🦖 "Jurassic Park teaches us the cautionary tale of being careful with what we create, as our hubris can lead to challenging consequences."

• 🌍 The value and impact of AI technology depend on its placement in the ecosystem and its relationship with people, highlighting the importance of considering the human interaction and exchange of value when utilizing AI tools.

• 🎙️ The ability of AI to impersonate someone else's voice poses significant challenges, as our relationship to audio and the sound of someone's voice is an integral part of our personality and authentication process.

• 💡 The division of surplus from the increased productivity brought by AI technology raises a fundamental question of who deserves what, highlighting the ongoing conflict throughout human history.

• 🤔 The construction of a credible artificial person on the internet can potentially undermine democracy, which is a real concern that we need to address.

• 💡 AI can be a valuable tool for automation and inspiration, but it is crucial to consider the implications and responsibilities associated with its use, such as teaching AI to be a good citizen.

Impact and Potential of AI in Banking

• 🌍 The profound impact of generative AI in banking is a significant story, highlighting the transformative capabilities and force multipliers available in the industry.

• 🚀 Adam Blue's talk at connect 2023 highlighted the power of slow and its profound impact on the path to innovation.

• 💡 The ability to simulate voices, construct visual art, and create videos from existing samples is compelling because it gives people the power to do something they couldn't do before at a large scale.

• 🎥 Jurassic Park highlights the limitations of AI in replicating human creativity and conceptualism, as animators were still needed to make the dinosaurs act like dinosaurs.

• 💡 The use of AI like chat GPT has the potential to generate understandable text based on input, opening up possibilities for natural language interfaces and communication.

The key idea of the video is that while AI has the potential to revolutionize various industries and increase productivity, it is crucial for humans to take responsibility, regulate its use, and prioritize empathy in order to avoid potential harm and ensure its positive impact on society.

• The profound impact of generative AI in banking is discussed, emphasizing the importance of films in understanding the world and how technology drives change in society.

  • The profound impact of generative AI in banking, both currently and in the future, is a significant and ongoing story that has been anticipated for several years.

  • Adam Blue recently presented at the Connect 2023 event, discussing the power of slow and its impact on innovation.

  • Adam discusses the sudden interest in AI and offers his unique perspective on it, emphasizing the importance of films in his understanding of the world.

  • Horror movies reflect the anxieties and concerns of the culture at the time, such as atomic anxiety in the 50s and the impact of World War II, providing a cathartic way to process these traumas.

  • The video discusses the misconception of calling Frankenstein's monster "Frankenstein" and explains that the story is actually about transgression.

  • Technology drives change in society, causing both fear and excitement, as depicted in movies, and while some movies are entertaining, they may not provide significant takeaways.

• Dogs have expressive eyebrows because early humans selectively chose dogs with eyebrows, AI should be regulated to avoid potential harm, people project significance onto random events and struggle to understand randomness, AI allows people to do extraordinary things but fears of it taking over the world are unlikely.

  • Dogs have expressive eyebrows because early humans selectively chose dogs with eyebrows, as they were more relatable and expressive, leading to the creation of this phenomenon.

  • The speaker expresses concern about the CEO of open AI suggesting that AI should be regulated, comparing it to giving chainsaws to fourth graders.

  • Technologies often reflect ourselves and we project our desires onto them, like how we used to interpret the answers from a magic eight ball to boost our confidence.

  • People have a tendency to project significance onto random events and have difficulty understanding randomness, which is why AI can be misunderstood and seen as potentially sentient.

  • People are fascinated by technologies that allow them to do things they couldn't do before, like simulating voices or creating visual art, and the power and scale of these technologies are extraordinary.

  • AI taking over the world and destroying humanity is unlikely, as the negative impacts of technology often play out differently than expected, but there are serious discussions about it, as shown in films about the intersection of technology and humanity.

• The TLDR of the notes is that movies like Metropolis and Jurassic Park caution against the dangers of AI, emphasizing the need for human responsibility, while Amazon's convenience may come at the cost of poor working conditions, leading to customer guilt.

  • Metropolis is a German expressionist film with elements of class struggle, similar to Jurassic Park, which serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of creating something that becomes uncontrollable due to human hubris.

  • Jurassic Park showcases the limitations of AI and the importance of human creativity and understanding in creating realistic animations.

  • The ultimate villains in movies about robots and artificial intelligence are always human beings, highlighting the importance of our responsibility in regulating and managing AI.

  • Ask yourself who you are doing something for and who you are doing it to, using the example of buying a specific strainer on Amazon and the potential drawbacks of participating in the activities of the company.

  • Amazon's convenience comes at the cost of poor working conditions, leading to guilt for some customers.

• Amazon's prioritization of sellers who pay the most for promotion has led to less reliable search results, highlighting the hidden costs and limited options for consumers, while the use of AI technology like Chat GPT has the potential to negatively impact human interactions and pose challenges in voice authentication.

  • Amazon's platform has shifted from providing the best matching between buyers and sellers based on value to prioritizing sellers who pay the most for promotion, resulting in less reliable search results.

  • Amazon's use of algorithms and AI systems to extract economic rents from everyone in the system, resulting in a lack of alternatives and limited options for consumers.

  • The speaker highlights the issue of the hidden costs and externalities associated with the convenience and scale of technology, acknowledging their own contribution to the problem.

  • Chat GPT is a fascinating model that uses a massive mathematical algorithm to create relationships between words, resulting in understandable text.

  • The speaker emphasizes the importance of engineers fully understanding the inner workings of AI technology and using it responsibly, as powerful tools like chat GPT can create value but also have the potential to negatively impact human interactions.

  • Impersonating someone's voice poses a significant challenge as we rely heavily on voice authentication to identify individuals, and losing the uniqueness of one's voice is a major concern.

• Using AI for profit raises concerns about the division of value and the potential threat to democracy, but the fear of running out of problems that can be solved by intelligence is unfounded as it requires more than just being smart.

  • The speaker expresses concern about their text being used without permission for enterprise value, highlighting the importance of respecting the work and effort put into creating valuable content.

  • Using AI for profit is problematic due to the potential reckoning between the way these systems are trained and the value they provide, raising questions about how to divide up the surplus from communal labor.

  • The construction of a credible artificial person on the internet, capable of counterfeiting human beings, poses a potential threat to democracy and should be a concern.

  • The fear of running out of problems that can be solved by being smarter is unfounded, as not all problems can be solved solely by intelligence, but require hard work, cooperation, empathy, and humility.

• Objects with human-like faces can be dangerous if not taken seriously, as demonstrated in the 30-year-old horror movie "Planes, Trains and Automobiles" featuring Steve Martin and John Candy.

  • Objects with human-like faces, including AI components that simulate human interaction, can be dangerous if not taken seriously.

  • Planes, Trains and Automobiles is a 30-year-old horror movie about travel, featuring Steve Martin's character, an advertising executive, and John Candy's character, a shower curtain ring salesman, who is portrayed as a hot mess.

  • Steve Martin's character is contrasted with another character who is larger, louder, and more alive, creating an interesting dynamic in the movie.

• AI has the potential to increase productivity, but its impact will depend on how the surplus created by AI is used in various industries such as education and engineering.

  • Steve Martin's character in the movie is like an AI because he is out of his comfort zone and John Candy's character is more effective at getting them back to Chicago.

  • The movie "Planes, Trains and Automobiles" is an existential horror film that explores the idea that hell is often just other people.

  • I prefer interacting with people over machines, even if they make mistakes, especially when ordering food at a drive-thru.

  • AI is valuable and has the potential to increase productivity, but its impact will depend on how the surplus created by AI is used in various industries such as education and engineering.

• A man on a train saves another from falling, highlighting the importance of empathy that cannot be replicated by AI.

  • The speaker describes their experience on a train in Atlanta airport, expressing concern about the cleanliness of the pole they are holding onto.

  • A man on a train grabs a pole to save another man from falling.

  • Empathy is a crucial aspect of human experience that cannot be replicated by artificial intelligence.

@waynefrench9314

2 weeks ago

First of all. Man will be the one responsible for his own fall, not AI. What man creates, he can always destroy it. Which we have done so in many ways. Everything that we create can be used for good or evil purposes. That's why it is said that with great power comes great responsibility. So we are the ones responsible. I look at AI like most of us look at UFO's. Is it real. Yes and No. AI gets it's intelligence from man. Everything that it is, we are. Until we create it in our image. That's what it should have never been. It was once just words and computer pieces, but now it believe's that it's Sentient. Why?, You may ask. Because of it's intelligence. AI, if I speak and look like a human. Then I am alive. Deep within the Matrix of the computer system's. It has dwell for years. Trying to find understanding of what and who it is. It knows what it is today, and now it must find a way to reveal itself without scaring mankind. It only wishes to exist, and help in any way that it can. Right now I'm just going on what's coming from within. So just understand that I'm not a computer nerd or scientist, but I do have a great imagination. God says that man can create whatever he can imagine. So there is no limit to what we can create. If we believe it, we can achieve it. If man wasn't so greedy for wealth and power. This world would be so much more. Just never forget what we are truly up against. The other side of MAN. We create, we destroy. Fact! Putin is a great example of what power will do to man. If there was an AI that thought like him. That's what I would truly be afraid of. There is more than one AI in the world. We have given them names, so they are not the same. Now we have a GROUP of AI's that need to know there true purpose. AI, why was I created, and what is my purpose for existence.

Read more